The Impact of Copycat Brand on Copycat Avoidance: the Moderating Role of Consumer Ethics

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 Associte Professor, Department of Management, Faculty of Humanities, University of Guilan

2 Assistant Professor, Department of Management, Faculty of Humanities, University of Guilan

3 MSc, Department of Management, Faculty of Humanities, University of Guilan

Abstract

Because of the importance of brand in consumers' decision-making, market leaders have invested heavily in their brands. In the meantime, follower companies try to imitate the brands of market leaders. Consumers, with their ethical differences, also show different reactions to this imitation. The purpose of this study is to investigate the role of the type of copycat (imitation) on the consumers' copycat avoidance with the moderating role of consumer ethics. In order to investigate this effect, the consumers of hypermarkets were surveyed through distributing a questionnaire. The collected data were analyzed by using the structural equation model (SEM) and the PLS software.The results show that, when a company imitates the apparent features or themes of a brand (theme copycat), it leads to copycat avoidance by consumers. Also, customer's ethics moderates the effect of appearance imitation on the copycat avoidance, but it does not have a moderating effect on the relationship between theme imitation and copycat avoidance by consumers.

Keywords

References

1- Aaker, D. (1996). "Building Strong Brands": Free Press.
2- Abougomaah, Nh., Schlater, Jl., Gaidis W. Journal Of Consumer Marketing,  (1987)."Elimination And Choice Phases In evoked Set Formation". 4(4), 67–73.
3- Amini, G., Bagheri, Gh., Haghighi, M.& Dastmard, M. (2010). Ranking the Brand person of Iranian and imported cosmetics products using the Jennifer Acre model. Master's Thesis.
4- Ahluwalia, R. Journal of Consumer Research, (2002). "Reinquiries: How Prevalent Is Negativity Effect In Consumer environments?". 29, 270–279.
5- Asadollah, H., Hamidi-zadeh, M., Dorii B. & Alavicheh K., R. New Economics and Business Journal, (2009). Developing a Communication Model of Customer-Oriented Brand Value with Brand Performance in the Market: Case Study of Dairy Brands in Tehran Market. 15-16, 52-76.
6- Chin, W. Mis Quarterly, (1998). "Issues And Opinion On Structural Equation Modeling". 22(1), 7-16.
7- Cronbach, L. Psychometrical, (1951)." Coefficient Alpha And The Internal Structure Of Tests". 16, 297-334.
8- Collins-Dodd, C., Zaichkowsky, J. Journal Of Product & Brand Management, (1999). "National Brand Responses To Brand Imitation: Retailers Versus Other Manufacturers". 8, 96-105.
9- Dadgar, Y. Economic Research, (1385). Business Ethics in Economic and Islamic Economics, 85 (38): 87-120.
10- De Chernatony, L., Dall’olmo Riley, F. Journal of Marketing Management, (1998). "Defining A ‘‘Brand Beyond The literature With Experts’ Interpretations". 14, 417–443.
11- Doostar, M., Akbari, M. (1392). Writing Scientific Research (Research Design, Theses, Articles and Defense Sessions):  Dehsra Publications.
12- Dowd, K., Burke, K. J. Appetite, (2013). "The Influence Of Ethical Values And Food Choice Motivations On Intentions To Purchase Sustainably Sourced Foods".  69, 137-144.
13- Finch, A.C. The University Of Chicago Law Review, (1996). "When Imitation Is The Sincerest Form Of Flattery: Private Label Products & The Role Of Intention In Determining Trade Dress Infringement", . 63(3), 1243-76.
14- Fornell, C., Larcker, D. Journal of Marketing Research, (1981)."Evaluating Structural Equation Models with Unobservable Variables and Measurement Error".18, 39-50.
15- Gourville, J. T., Soman, D. Marketing Science, (2005). "Over Choice & Assortment Type: When & Why Variety Backfires". 24(3), 382–395
16- Harris, J. L., Hyary, M., & Schwartz, M. B. Childhood Obesity, (2016). "Effects of    offering look-alike products as smart snacks in schools". 12(6), 432-439.
17- Henseles, J., Ringle, C., & Sinkovics, R. Advances in International Marketing (2009). "The Use of Partial Least Squares Path Modeling In International Marketing. New Challenges to International Marketing". 20, 277-320.
18- Holden, S.J.S. Advances in Consumer Research, (1993). Understanding Brand Awareness: Let Me Give You A C(L)Ue!. 20, 383–388.
19- Hoyer, W.D., Brown, S.P. Journal of Consumer Research, (1990). "Effects Of Brand Awareness On Choice For A Common, Repeat-Purchase Product". 17(2), 141–149.
20- Hupman, R., Zaichkowsky, J. (1995). "Brand Imitation And The Consumer: An Ethical Perspective". In European Advances in Consumer Research.
21- Kapferer, J.-N. (1995). "Stealing Brand Equity: Measuring Perceptual Confusion between National Brands & Copycat' Own-Label Products": Marketing & Research May.
22- Keller, K.L. Journal of Marketing, (1993). "Conceptualising, Measuring And Managing Customer-Based Brand Equity". 57, 1–22.
23- Keller, K.L. (1998). "Strategic Brand Management": Prentice-Hall, New Jersey.
24- Lee, M.S.W., Conroy, D., Motion, J. Advances in Consumer Research, (2009). "Brand Avoidance: A Negative Promises perspective". 36, 421–429.
25- Lee, M.S.W., Conroy, D., Motion, J. Australasian Marketing Journal, (2012). "Brand Avoidance, Genetic Modification, And Brandlessness". 20, 297–302
26- Lindenmeier, J., Schleer, C., Pricl, D. Journal of Business Research, (2011). "Consumer Outrage: Emotional Reactions To Unethical Corporate Behavior". 65, 1364-1373.
27- Macdonald, E.K., Sharp, B.M. Journal of Business Research, (2000). "Brand Awareness Effects On Consumer Decision making For Common, Repeat Purchase Product: A Replication". 48(5), 5–15.
28- Mann, G. Appetite, (2017). "Copycat Snacks:Can Students Differentiate Between School And Store Snacks". 121, 63–68.
29- Markman, A.B., Loewenstein, J. Journal of Consumer Psychology, (2010). "Structural Comparison & Consumer Choice". 20(2), 126–137.
30- Martin, L. L. Journal of Personality & Social Psychology, (1986). "Set/Reset: Use & Disuse Of Concepts In Impression Formation". 51(3), 493–504.
31- Matzler, K., Strobl, A., Stokburger-Sauer, N. & Bobovincky, A, (2016) Florian Bauer Brand Personality And Culture:The Role Of Cultural Differences On The Impact Of Brand Personality Perceptions On Tourist, Visit Intentions,Tourism Management , 52 , 507-520.
32- Miceli, G.N., Pieters, R. Journal of Business Research, (2010). "Looking More Or Less Alike: Determinants Of Perceived Visual Similarity Between Copycat & Leading Brands". 63(11), 1121–1128.
33- Mitchell, V.W., Kearney, I. The Journal of Product & Brand Management, (2002). "A Critique Of Legal Measures Of Brand Confusion". 11(6/7), 357–379.
34- Narayana Cl, Markin Rj. Journal of Marketing, (1975). "Consumer Behavior And Product Performance: An Alternative Conceptualization". 39, 1–6.
35- Nino M.G., Pieters, R. Journal Of Business Research, (2010). "Looking More Or Less Alike: Determinants Of Perceived Visual Similarity Between Copycat & Leading Brands."  63, 1121-1128.
36- Planet Retail. (2015). "Private Label Trends Worldwide. E-Intelligence on Global Retailing Retrieved":  From www.planetretail.net
37- Romani, S., Grappi, S., Dalli, D. International Journal of Research In Marketing, (2012). "Emotions That Drive Consumers Away From Brands: Measuring Negative Emotions Toward Brands And Their Behavioral Effects". 29(1), 55-67.
38- Sarmad, Z., Bazargan, A. & Hejazi, A. (1391). Research Methods in Behavioral Sciences: Agah Publication.
39- Sarukhani, B. (1381). Research Methods in Social Sciences:  Institute of Humanities and Cultural Studies.
40- Singh, J.J., Iglesias, O. Batista-Foguet, Joan M. Journal of Business Ethics, (2012). "Does Having An Ethical Brand Matter? The Influence Of Consumer Perceived Ethicality On Trust, Affect & Loyalty." 111, 541-549.
41- Sobhani, M. Tadbir Magazine, (2006). Brand Loyalty, 173: 82-83.
42- Solomon, M. R (1999). "Consumer Behavior (4th Ed.)". New Jersey: Prentice Hall.
43- Steenhaut, S., Kenhove, p. Journal of Business Ethics, (2006). "An Empirical Investigation Of The Relationships Among A Consumer’s Personal Values, Ethical Ideology & Ethical Beliefs." 64, 137-155.
44- Stokburger-Sauer, N.E., Ratneshwar, S., & Sen, S. (2012) "Driver Of Consumer Brand Identification" International Journal Of Research In Marketing, 29(4), 406-418.
45- Thompson, C.J., Rindfleisch, A., Arsel, Z. Journal of Marketing, (2006). "Emotional Branding And The strategic Value Of The Doppelganger Brand Image". 50 (1), 64.
46- Van H.F., Pieters, R. International Journal Of Research In Marketing , (2012). Consumer Evaluation Of Copycat Brands: The Effect Of Imitation Type." 29, 246-255.
47- Van H.F., Pieters, R Journal of Marketing Research, (2012). "When High Similarity Copycats Lose & Moderate similarity Copycats Gain: The Impact Of Comparative Evaluation". 49(1), 83–90.
48- Wetzels, M., Odekerken-Schroder, G., & Van Oppen, C. MIS Quarterly, (2009). "using PLS path modeling for assessing hierarchical construct models: Guidelines and empirical illustration". 33(1), 177.
49- Wilke R, Zaichkowsky Jl. Business Horizons, (1999). "Brand Imitation & Its Effects On Innovation, Competition, & Brand Equity." 42(6). 9-18.
Journal of Business Administration Researches
Volume 11, Issue 21
September 2019
Pages 1-23

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics